Brits from BAME backgrounds ARE more likely to die of Covid-19, Public Health England review confirms – while the disease is 70 TIMES more likely to kill over-80s, diabetes is a major risk factor and men in lower-paid jobs are dying at ‘significant’ rates
- Health chiefs launched a probe on the impact of Covid-19 on black, Asian and minority ethnic Brits in April
- An array of evidence has revealed white people are much less likely to die from the coronavirus
- The Public Health England report, published today after a May deadline, confirms the increased risk
- Here’s how to help people impacted by Covid-19
Black, Asian and minority ethnic (BAME) people are more likely to die from Covid-19, a government review has confirmed.
The Public Health England (PHE) report revealed Britons of Bangladeshi ethnicity had around twice the risk of white Brits of dying with the coronavirus.
And it showed black people, as well as those of Chinese, Indian, Pakistani, other Asian, or Caribbean backgrounds had between a 10 and 50 per cent higher risk of death. The analysis did not take into account higher rates of long-term health conditions among these people, which experts say probably account for some of the differences.
Evidence compiled in the report also revealed that age is the single biggest risk factor that determines how likely people are to die with the virus – those over the age of 80 are 70 times more likely to be killed than under-40s.
And health conditions which appeared often on people’s death certificates were heart disease, diabetes – understood to be type 2 diabetes, high blood pressure and dementia. More than one in five victims had diabetes, the data showed, which was a significantly higher rate than in people who died of other causes.
Poorer, more deprived people faced a higher risk of dying and men working in lower-paid jobs – such as security guards, bus drivers and construction workers – also had worse chances of survival if they contracted the virus.
Health chiefs launched a probe to investigate the disproportionate impact of Covid-19 on BAME Brits in April, prompted by a wave of evidence that showed white people were less likely to die from the disease.
Health Secretary Matt Hancock, speaking in Parliament today, said: ‘Black lives matter,’ and pledged action to try and reduce health inequalities between different communities in the UK.
He was pushed to deny that the release of the report – which was supposed to happen in May – had not been delayed because of political tensions in the wake of the death of American man George Floyd. He said in the House of Commons: ‘We’ve published it and brought it to the House at the earliest possible opportunity.’
Mr Hancock admitted that the report has ‘exposed huge disparities in the health of our nation’ and his counterpart in the Labour Party, Shadow Health Secretary Jonathan Ashworth, noted: ‘Covid thrives on inequalities’.
Doctors still don’t know exactly what is increasing non-white people’s risk of death, but PHE’s report adds to a growing body of evidence proving the link exists. One paper presented to government advisers in SAGE suggested that higher-than-average rates of type 2 diabetes among black and south Asian people may be to blame – the condition is known to increase risk of Covid-19 death.
And another study done by King’s College Hospital in London found that BAME coronavirus patients there were, on average, 11 years younger than the white patients – 63 compared to 74.
The Public Health England report found:
- Covid-19 diagnosis rates – which reflect the numbers of people with serious disease – were higher in older age groups for both sexes;
- Death became considerably more likely with age. Compared with under-40s, the risk of death was tripled for people in their 40s, nine times higher among people in their 50s, 27 times higher among people in their 60s, 50 times higher for those in their 70s and a staggering 70 times higher for over-80s;
- Working age men diagnosed with the virus were twice as likely to die as women of the same age;
- Urban areas have considerably higher death rates from the virus – that of London was more than treble what was seen in the South West of England;
- People living in the most deprived areas of England were more likely both to be diagnosed with the virus and also to die of it. This may be because they had riskier jobs or lived in densely-populated areas where the virus could spread;
- Black, Asian and ethnic minority people faced a greater risk of dying with the coronavirus than white people. Reasons are unclear but greater prevalence of serious health conditions is thought to contribute;
- Medical workers are at a higher risk of catching or dying with the coronavirus. The PHE report repeated findings from the Office for National Statistics that men in less well-paid jobs were also at higher risk;
- Diabetes, mainly type 2 diabetes, is found at significantly higher rates among people who died of Covid-19 than in people who died of other causes, suggesting it increases risk. The same was found to be true of high blood pressure, kidney disease and dementia.
Data in the Public Health England report showed that the mortality rate – the number of people dying with the coronavirus out of each 100,000 people – was considerably higher for black men than other group. The risk for black women, people of Asian ethnicity, and mixed race people was also higher than for white people of either sex. The report warned the rate for the ‘Other’ category was ‘likely to be an overestimate’
Covid-19 can be seen to have had a significant effect on the numbers of men dying (dark green) in all ethnic groups but particularly for black and Asian men
Covid-19 can be seen to have had a significant effect on the numbers of women dying (dark green) in all ethnic groups but particularly for black and Asian women
Black men and women appeared to be at much higher risk of getting diagnosed with Covid-19, compared to other ethnic groups. The ‘Other’ group is not likely to be accurate because of disparities in the data and small numbers
While white people make up a majority of Covid-19 hospital cases, they are more likely to be treated on normal wards with less severe infection. For adults in all other ethnic groups, however, there are higher rates of intensive care admission than there are admissions for low-level care
The highest diagnosis rates per 100,000 population were in black people (486 females and 649 males), the PHE review found. The lowest were in white people (220 in females and 224 in males).
Compared to previous years, death from all causes was almost four times higher than expected among black males, almost three times higher in Asian males and almost two times higher in white males.
Among females, deaths were almost three times higher in this period in black, mixed and other females, and 2.4 times higher in Asian females compared with 1.6 times in white females.
The highest death rates of confirmed cases per 100,000 population were among people in ‘other’ ethnic groups (234 females and 427 males) followed by people of black ethnic groups (119 females and 257 males) and Asian ethnic groups (78 females and 163 males).
In comparison, the death rates of confirmed cases in white people was 36 per 100,000 females and 70 per 100,000 males.
Facing questions in Parliament today about why the release of the report had been pushed back, Matt Hancock denied it was because of increased sensitivity about racism in the light of protests and riots in the US.
Crowds gathered in London, Manchester and Cardiff over the weekend to demonstrate against institutional racism, as widespread protests continue in the US after a white policeman killed an unarmed black man, George Floyd, by kneeling on his neck for nine minutes.
Conservative MP for East Surrey, Clair Coutinho, asked whether this had factored into a decision not to release the report on time. Mr Hancock said: ‘I can absolutely confirm that [it hasn’t].’
SAGE STUDY CLAIMS ILLNESS AND DEPRIVATION ACCOUNT FOR HIGHER DEATH RATE AMONG BAME BRITONS
Black, Asian and minority ethnic people are no more likely to die from coronavirus than white people, a study given to government scientists has found.
Research presented to Number 10’s SAGE panel found there was no greater risk of death for Brits of BAME backgrounds when all factors were taken into account.
It showed that ‘comorbidities’ – long-term health problems – appeared to account for higher rates of hospitalisation and intensive care among ethnic minority people.
Risk among BAME communities has been a sensitive topic during Britain’s outbreak and even given rise to calls for extra protection for non-white NHS staff.
Statistics show BAME people in Britain are dying of COVID-19 at disproportionate rates, but scientists have struggled to explain why.
The research – done by scientists from the universities of Edinburgh and Liverpool – was one of around a dozen secret papers published last night by the government.
It did, however, claim BAME people did seem to be more likely to end up in intensive care in the first place.
The SAGE paper was met with scepticism, however, with one intensive care doctor saying the data it contained did not line up with what the scientists claimed.
Oxford University’s Professor Duncan Young said: ‘I’m not sure why they thought black patients were more at risk of ICU care.
‘The take-home message is that BAME patients admitted to hospital with COVID-19 are no more likely to end up in ICU nor are they more likely to die.’
The Health Secretary added: ‘When I asked PHE to undertake this piece of work I asked them to produce it by the end of May, which they did.
‘They delivered it to me on Sunday and we’ve published it and brought it to the House at the earliest possible opportunity.’
Mr Hancock admitted the report has exposed inequality across the UK and that non-white people were suffering worse health and now dying of coronavirus because of their social standing.
Black, Asian and minority ethnic people have higher rates of type 2 diabetes and high blood pressure, which increase the risk of someone dying if they catch Covid-19.
They are also twice as likely as white people to live in poverty, more likely to have lower-paid jobs, and more likely to live in densely-populated areas of cities and towns which may put them at higher risk of catching the coronavirus.
Mr Hancock said of the PHE report: ‘This is very timely work. People are understandably angry about injustices and as Health Secretary I feel a deep responsibility because this pandemic has exposed huge disparities in the health of our nation.
‘It is very clear that some people are significantly more vulnerable to Covid-19 and this is something I’m determined to understand in full and take action to address.’
He added: ‘Black lives matter, as do those of the poorest areas of our country which have worse health outcomes, and we need to make sure all of these considerations are taken into account, and action is taken to level-up the health outcomes of people across this country.
‘Because there’s no more important levelling-up than the levelling-up of your life expectancy and the quality of health with which you live that life.’
Shadow Health and Social Care Secretary Jonathan Ashworth said in Parliament: ‘We’ve always known that there was a social gradient in health – the poorest and most deprived have inequality in access to health care and an inequality in health outcomes.
‘What [Mr Hancock] has confirmed today is that Covid thrives on inequalities.
‘Yes, indeed, black lives matter but it is surely a call to action that black, Asian and minority ethnic people are more likely to die from Covid and more likely to be admitted to intensive care from Covid.’
According to data from the Office for National Statistics, black men and women are four times more likely to suffer a coronavirus-related death than white people.
Age: Older people are more likely to die with Covid-19
PHE’s report found that someone’s age was the single biggest factor that made them more likely to die with Covid-19. The older someone is, the higher their risk of dying.
Public Health England’s data showed there were considerably more cases of coronavirus among older age groups
They were also more likely to be diagnosed because their risk of severe disease was higher, meaning they were more likely to end up in hospital and therefore get tested.
Analysing survival among confirmed coronavirus patients, the report found the risk of death was three times as high for people aged between 40 and 49 as it was for under-40s.
Compared with under-40s, the risk of death was nine times higher among people in their 50s, 27 times higher among people in their 60s, 50 times higher for those in their 70s and a staggering 70 times higher for over-80s.
The report said: ‘These are the largest disparities by far found in this analysis’.
Illness: Heart disease, diabetes and dementia most common among Covid-19 victims
People with ‘underlying health conditions’ have been at the heart of fears about the coronavirus and the Public Health England report shows they are at considerably higher risk of dying with the disease.
The most common condition among people who died with the virus was heart disease, which was found in almost half of patients, but this rate was comparable to its prevalence in people who die of any condition.
Diabetes, however – understood to refer to type 2 diabetes – was found in 21.1 per cent of Covid-19 victims, compared to just 14.6 per cent of people who died of any cause. This shows it increases the risk of dying of the coronavirus.
The risk was also higher for high blood pressure (hypertensive diseases), which was found in 19.6 per cent of Covid-19 victims but only 14.5 per cent of all deaths.
Dementia was also slightly higher, at 25.7 per cent from 23.8 per cent, along with kidney disease and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
The report added: ‘Several studies, although measuring the different outcomes from Covid-19, report an increased risk of adverse outcomes in obese or morbidly obese people.’
Cardiovascular (heart) disease, type 2 diabetes and dementia are found to be the conditions most common among people who die with the coronavirus. Heart disease is more common among Bangladeshi and Pakistani communities than among white people, and type 2 diabetes is more common in BAME people. Dementia is more common in white people
Occupation: Men in lower-paid jobs the most at risk
The PHE report said that healthcare workers made up more than 10,000 confirmed coronavirus cases at the time it was compiled, which was likely a direct result of their jobs.
It repeated a finding from the Office for National Statistics (ONS) last month that men working in lower-paid jobs ‘had significantly higher death rates from Covid-19’ along with both men and women working in social care.
As examples of the men whose jobs appeared to put them at risk it said security guards, taxi drivers, chauffeurs, bus drivers, chefs, retail assistants, construction workers and factory employees were dying at higher rates.
Reasons for this are unclear but this may be because those people are more likely to come into contact with others and therefore to catch the virus, or they are likely to have poorer health if they are not well paid.
The PHE report said: ‘For many occupations, however, the number of deaths is too small to draw meaningful conclusions and further analysis will be required.’
Public Health England data also found that at least 169 care workers and home carers have now died with coronavirus. Deaths among those in the care sector were 1.7 times higher during the pandemic compared to previous years and, between March 21 and May 8, there were 548 deaths of all causes among care workers and home carers.
Deprivation: Poorer people diagnosed more often and more likely to die
The PHE report showed that deaths were considerably higher in men in the most deprived communities, and both sexes saw a direct link between deprivation and Covid-19 death rate
People who live in the most deprived areas of the country are more likely to get seriously ill or die with the coronavirus, PHE’s report confirmed.
It said: ‘People who live in deprived areas have higher diagnosis rates and death rates than those living in less deprived areas.
‘The mortality rates from Covid-19 in the most deprived areas were more than double the least deprived areas, for both males and females.
‘This is greater than the inequality seen in mortality rates in previous years, indicating greater inequality in death rates from COVID-19.
‘High diagnosis rates may be due to geographic proximity to infections or a high proportion of workers in occupations that are more likely to be exposed.’
The report explained that higher diagnosis and death rates in poorer communities were still noticeable when people’s age and ethnicity were taken into account, but may have been influenced by higher rates of other illnesses such as type 2 diabetes, which PHE said ‘requires further investigation’.